Make a Payment
Pay My Bill
You can pay with a bank account using our e-check program. We also accept Visa, Mastercard, and Discover.
Phone
Call Customer Support at:
Monday – Friday 8:00am to 7:00pm ET
Saturday 8:00am – 4:30pm ET
Online
Log into the My Security First Customer Portal to check your balance, make payments, and more!
Payment Addresses
Standard Payment Mailing Address
Security First Insurance Company, PO Box 628336, Orlando, FL 32862-8336
FedEx & UPS Overnight Payment Address
Security First Insurance Company, Lockbox 628336, 7699 Golf Channel Drive Orlando, FL 32819
- Annual “Full Pay” = One payment
- Semi-Annual “2 Pay” = Two payments + fees
- Quarterly “4 Pay” = Four payments + fees
- Monthly = Monthly payments + fees
Flexible Payment Options
Please call Customer Support if you’d like to set up a convenient payment plan for your current policy term or if you need to change your payment method. Note: Once the first installment payment is made, your payment plan cannot be changed for the remainder of that policy term.