Make a Payment

Ways to Pay  

You can pay with a bank account using our e-check program.  
We also accept Visa, Mastercard, and Discover.

An illustration of a basic phone.

Call Customer Support at:

(877) 333-9992

Monday – Friday 
8:00 am to 7:00 pm ET

8:00 am to 4:30 pm ET



Mobile App

Make a payment wherever you are.


Log in for payments or billing information.



Express Pay

Make a payment without logging in.

An illustration of an envelope in a mailbox for making payments through the mail.

Payment Mailing Address
Security First Insurance Company
PO Box 628336
Orlando, FL 32862-8336

FedEx & UPS Overnight Payments
(Effective 04/17/2023)

Security First Insurance Company
Lockbox 628336
7699 Golf Channel Drive
Orlando, FL 32819

Payment Options

Please call Customer Support if you wish to set up a convenient payment plan
for your current policy term or if you wish to change your payment method. 
Note: Once the first installment is made, your payment plan
cannot be changed for the remainder of that policy term.

Annual "Full Pay"

An illustration of a hand holding a credit card

1 payment

Semi-Annual "2 Pay"


An illustration of two online payment confirmations

2 payments + fees

Quarterly "4 Pay"

An illustration of four online payment confirmations

4 payments + fees


An illustration of a monthly calendar

12 payments + fees