Make a Payment

Online Illustration
Pay Online

Use our online customer portal, My Security First, to make a payment online.

  • View policy information
  • Make your annual premium payment or utilize our 2-pay or 4-pay payment plans
Phone Illustration
Pay By Phone

To make a payment by phone, please call your insurance agent or our customer service department toll free at (877) 333-9992

You will then be connected to a customer service representative who will process the transaction and give you a confirmation code. We accept Visa, Mastercard, and Discover. You may also make a credit card payment using our free mobile app, Security First Mobile.

Pay By Mail Illustration
Mail Payment

To mail your payment via the United States Postal Service, please use the address below.

Security First Insurance
P.O. Box 628336
Orlando, Florida 32862-8336

Expedited Mail Payment (UPS & FedEx)

If you wish to send in your payment using an express or overnight delivery service, please use the following address:

Security First Insurance
Lockbox# 628336
102 W. Pineloch Ave., Suite 18
Orlando, Florida 32806-6100